Bryan Reynolds: Pirates Designated Hitter In 2026?
As bad as the Pittsburgh Pirates’ offense was collectively in 2025, you would expect Bryan Reynolds to be a reliable cog in the lineup. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case, as the veteran switch-hitter had his worst season at the plate; slashing .245/.318/.402, along with a career low 1.4 oWAR in 654 plate appearances.
The struggles on offense for Reynolds seemed to be expected. After all, the only protection in the lineup he received was from Oneil Cruz in the first half and Spencer Horwitz in the second half.
During his seven seasons in Pittsburgh, Reynolds has played all three outfield spots. The defense has been on a decline; registering -20 Defensive Runs Saved since 2022.
Reynolds’ current trade value combined with being owed $75.25 million over the next five years makes it very unlikely that the Pirates move him this winter. The Kansas City Royals reportedly had interest in trading for Reynolds during the summer, but it’s unclear what the level of interest was.
Andrew McCutchen was the Bucs primary designated hitter each of the last three seasons, and it seems 50/50 that he would return. If the Pirates decide to move on from McCutchen, then there’s a strong chance Reynolds moves into the DH role, and they address more than one outfielder.
Reynolds enters 2026 in his age 31 season. Based on track record, it’s possible that Reynolds is a bounce back candidate offensively, especially if his sole focus will be as a DH.