What Is a Realistic Expectation Level for Eli Holstein In 2025?
p/c: Gareth Patterson
Later this month, the Pittsburgh Panthers will be kicking off the 2025 college football season on August 30th against the Duquesne Dukes at Acrisure Stadium. It’s the first meeting between the two schools on the gridiron since 1939.
Eli Holstein enters this season as the Panthers starting quarterback as a redshirt sophomore. Last year, Holstein opened some eyes as one of the most impressive freshmen quarterbacks during the first half. However, the play from Holstein in the second half of the season wasn’t as efficient, and on top of that, he suffered a season-ending, ankle injury.
So what realistically can be the expectations for Holstein in 2025?
For Holstein, it’s another year in Kade Bell’s uptempo style offense, with a lot of returning starters, including receivers Kenny Johnson, CJ Lee, and Raphael Williams, tight end Jake Overman, and dynamic, tailback Desmond Reid.
A couple of transfers were added to the offensive line in Jeff Persi from Michigan and Kendall Staley from Charlotte. In an interview I did a month ago with Pitt football beat writer, Amanda Godsey, she mentioned that returning starters BJ Williams and Ryan Baer lost some weight during the offseason, in an effort to move around better in Bell’s offensive scheme,
At 6’4, 225, Holstein moves around well, and can run with the ball, if nothing is available down field. He has a strong arm, along with great acceleration on throws. The one knock on Holstein is his pocket awareness.
Pitt’s offense this season has a chance to be exciting again, given the amount of talent who’ll be returning. If Holstein can improve his presence in the pocket, with even more experience, and more importantly stay healthy, then he could be a Top 1-2 quarterback in the ACC this year, as well as possibly being a Top 10 QB in the nation.
Pirates to Activate Johan Oviedo on Monday
p/c: Chaz Palla - Pittsburgh TribLive
The Pittsburgh Pirates are set to activate right-hander Johan Oviedo from the injured list to make his 2025 season debut against the San Francisco Giants on Monday at PNC Park, this according to Noah Hiles of the Post-Gazette.
Left-hander Bailey Falter had been slated to pitch Monday’s game for the Pirates, but he was dealt to the Kansas City Royals at the trade deadline.
For Oviedo, he was originally suppose to start for AAA Indianapolis on Sunday, but given the Falter trade, it opened up a spot in the Pirates’ rotation.
Oviedo missed the entirety of 2024 recovering from Tommy John surgery. Before the injury, he posted a 4.31 ERA and had a 2.2 bWAR in 32 starts for Pittsburgh during the 2023 season.
In the early portion of spring training, Oviedo sustained a significant lat muscle strain, while throwing live BP, and had to be placed on the 60-day IL to begin the year.
Oviedo made five starts beginning in early July. His latest start was July 29th for Indianapolis, where he pitched five innings of one run ball versus the Iowa Cubs. Oviedo’s fastball velocity looked strong in that outing, as he sat 95-96 mph.
Embarrassing Trade Deadline a Microcosm for Pirates’ Lack of Direction
The 2025 Major League Baseball trade deadline came and went on Thursday. And for the Pittsburgh Pirates, it was lackluster, to say the least.Aside from the Adam Frazier trade a couple weeks ago, the Pirates dealt five players, including Ke’Bryan Hayes, Caleb Ferguson, David Bednar, Taylor Rogers, and Bailey Falter.
General manager Ben Cherington received a total of seven prospects. However, six of them are still years away at the A ball level. The only upper level prospect Cherington obtained was Rafael Flores, a catcher/first baseman in the Bednar deal, who was the New York Yankees eighth ranked prospect.
Despite Ke’Bryan Hayes’ offensive shortcomings, he was playing a perennial, Gold Glove caliber defense at third base, and had plenty of control, on a team-friendly extension. There really wasn’t a rush to move Hayes, especially when there isn’t a clear cut option waiting in the wings.
While it’s not much of a surprise Bednar was traded, because of pay escalation this offseason, it was the makings of a disappointing return. Objectively, Flores is a good prospect, but he should not have been the headliner in the deal. The other players, Edgleen Perez and Brian Sanchez, feel like lottery ticket prospects.
Rogers, acquired as part of the Hayes trade from the Cincinnati Reds, was flipped to the Chicago Cubs for a fringe, outfield prospect in Ivan Brethowr.
Perhaps the most confounding move for the Pirates at the deadline was the decision to part ways with Bailey Falter. Owed just $2.2 million, along with three more years of club control beyond this season, Falter was dealt to the Kansas City Royals in exchange for left-handed reliever Evan Sisk and first baseman Callen Moss. For Moss, he wasn’t even ranked on MLB Pipeline’s Top 30 Royals prospects list.
In regards to trading Falter, a team source had informed the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Noah Hiles that the motivation behind moving Falter is because he was being viewed as a non-tender candidate. Given Falter’s 3.73 ERA so far in 2025, it’s simply an asinine reason.
For as pathetic as last offseason was, in an effort to significantly improve the offense, this trade deadline was just as embarrassing - making it not only the worst of any team, but by far the worst of Cherington’s tenure in Pittsburgh.
If this had been the first or second year of a full rebuild, then these types of moves would be fine, as the goal would be to stockpile the farm system. But Cherington is in his sixth year as Pirates GM, and there’s even more questions now than answers.
With the amount of trades made, they have a good amount of cash to spend this offseason to address the offense. That being said, there’s been no concrete evidence to suggest that the Pirates are capable of effectively allocating their funds, for the good of the on field product.
From top to bottom, it’s a franchise in shambles. Whether it’s the super negative vibe surrounding owner Bob Nutting, team president Travis Williams assuring the fanbase that the food concessions, particularly their soft pretzels remain top notch, or Ben Cherington’s incompetence to giving the team no real sense of direction. For Pirates’ fans, there’s the desperate need to search for light at the end of the tunnel, but when it comes to this organization, that tunnel is being blocked off by a brick wall.
Breakdown of the Adam Frazier/Cam Devanney Trade Swap
Not even 24 hours after the MLB All-Star Game, the Pittsburgh Pirates made their first notable move of the trade season - dealing veteran utility man Adam Frazier to the Kansas City Royals in exchange for infielder Cam Devanney. The trade was first reported by Robert Murray of FanSided.
This marks the second time Frazier has been traded by the Pirates, as he was dealt by the Bucs to the San Diego Padres at the 2021 trade deadline for Jack Suwinski.
The 33-year-old Frazier had signed a one-year deal with Pittsburgh last offseason at $1.5 million. In 78 games this season, he slashed .255/.318/.336.
Devanney was a 15th round selection of the Milwaukee Brewers in the 2019 draft out of Elon University.
In December of 2023, the Brewers traded Devanney to the Royals, as part of a three-player deal.
Following a productive 2024 campaign playing at AAA Omaha (.781 OPS and 19 HR), Devanney has been even this year with Omaha; posting a .931 OPS with 18 HR.
Given that both Frazier and Devanney were on their respective 40-man rosters, no corresponding move needs to be made.
Assessment: Frazier played on the Royals’ 24 postseason team last year. He’ll get to reunite with a contender that is very much in the mix of a wide open American League wild card race. KC’s bench is mostly right-handed, so Frazier gives them a veteran lefty batter, who puts together competitive at-bats and doesn’t strike out much.
From the Pirates’ point of view, Devanney is a shortstop with offensive upside - something that is lacking at the position depth-wise. Defensively, he’s considered average at short.
Devanney was never going to receive the chance to be the Royals primary shortstop, since they obviously have Bobby Witt Jr. there for many years to come.
With the Bucs expected to move Isiah Kiner-Falefa before, or at the deadline, I would expect Devanney to get full run as the Pirates everyday shortstop.
A rental Adam Frazier wasn’t going to bring back much, which is better that the Pirates opted for an upper-minors player with some upside being blocked in another system, as opposed to an A ball “lottery ticket” that you cross your fingers on.
How Soon Could the Penguins Contend Under Dan Muse?
p/c: Giuseppe LoPiccolo - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
On April 28th, the Pittsburgh sports scene and general hockey landscape was abuzz, as it was announced that the Penguins and Mike Sullivan had mutually agreed to part ways.
Following 10 seasons, which included a pair of Stanley Cups, Sullivan’s style of coaching seemed to get stale after a while, with the team not winning a playoff series since 2018, as well as missing the playoffs in each of the last three seasons.
Although there was no official reason, it appeared that Sullivan and Penguins’ president of hockey operations, Kyle Dubas, weren’t getting on the same page - regarding the direction of the team.
On June 4th, Dubas hired Dan Muse as the 23rd head coach in franchise history. Perhaps more noteworthy is Muse possibly being the doppelgänger of Pittsburgh Pirates broadcaster Joe Block.
The soon-to-be 43-year-old Muse has an extensive developmental background, including the USA Hockey National Team Development Program, where he helped trained the likes of Pittsburgh native and Utah Mammoth center Logan Cooley, and Penguins top prospect Rutger McGroarty.
Muse’s coaching staff is now fully intact, with Todd Nelson, who was thought to be a strong candidate for the Penguins head coaching gig, former NHL forward Rich Clune, Mike Stothers, the return of goalie coach Andy Chiodo, and two-time Stanley Cup winner and Pens fan favorite Nick Bonino. For Bonino specifically, he mentioned to members of the Penguins’ media that he will be coaching the younger centers, in addition to helping out on the penalty kill.
When it comes to free agent additions, it’s not a surprise that Dubas has been playing it conservatively, despite the team’s breathing room in cap space. Muse’s first seasonin Pittsburgh is expected to be a transition.
To what degree of transition remains to be seen, as a lot will hinge on what type of offers Dubas receives this offseason for Bryan Rust and Rickard Rakell. Internally, there’s probably been discussion of wanting to get out from under Erik Karlsson’s large contract.
The biggest key for the Penguins under Dan Muse will be giving young players a legitimate opportunity, to claim roles on the roster. Top prospects Ville Koivunen and Rutger McGroarty are the two noteworthy forwards - the latter likely getting a chance to play along with Sidney Crosby on the top line. Guys like Owen Pickering and Harrison Brunicke will be top-tier defensive prospects looking to make an impact on Pittsburgh’s blue line.
In all likelihood, it should take the Penguins about four years to truly compete again. The first couple seasons for Muse will be a transition period. By the third season, the team could start to see their young core of talent starting to come together as a cohesive unit. Going into Year 4 should be when Dubas is able to spend plenty on the free agent market, and surround the players entering their primes, with quality, veteran compliments. At that point, it should be where the Pens become legit players again in the Eastern Conference, as opposed to a team that’s just “good enough”, and barely sneaks into the playoffs - only to get bounced in the first round.
Pitt Football Interview with Amanda Godsey
With the Pittsburgh Panthers kicking off their season against the Duquesne Dukes on August 30th at Acrisure Stadium, I had the opportunity to talk all things Pitt football with Amanda Godsey, who covers the team for the Johnstown Tribune-Democrat.
Shetler: In his first year as Pitt offensive coordinator last season, how would you assess Kade Bell’s offensive approach?
Godsey: I like what Kade Bell wants to do on offense. He wants to go up-tempo because it doesn’t allow defenses to substitute and it simplifies the offense for his players, in a way. He gives his QBs the freedom to tuck the ball and run if there’s nothing open. I thought the offense had some nice showings early in the season last year. For the offense to truly work the way it’s intended, the offensive line has to be better. It was tough last year because the offensive linemen on the roster were recruited for Frank Cignetti’s pro-style offense; Bell’s offense relies on athletic and fast guys who happen to be big playing offensive line. They’ve added some transfers that better fit that mold while guys like Ryan Baer and BJ Williams have lost some weight during the offseason to better fit the scheme as well.
I don’t think we’ve seen all of Bell’s offense yet and believe we’ll see more of it this fall.
Shetler: What does Eli Holstein need to do to be an even better quarterback in 2025?
Godsey: Trust his receivers and trust his ankle. Eli’s legs are what make him dynamic, so we’ll see how he recovers from off-season ankle surgery. He didn’t look entirely comfortable with it this spring even in his dropbacks, but by the time Pitt’s training camp begins, he’ll have had another 3 1/2 months since spring ball ended to recover.
He talked last year about maybe not trusting his receivers enough, particularly early in games early in the season. I expect him to get better this season after playing in Bell’s system for a year and just getting some college football game experience, which he didn’t have prior to last season.
Shetler: Which three players impressed you the most during Pitt spring ball?
Godsey: QB Mason Heintschel, LB Jeremiah Marcelin, CB Shadarian Harrison.
Heintschel seemed to take to the offense quickly. Marcelin is looking to compete with Braylan Lovelace for the starting middle linebacker job. Harrison took advantage of getting more reps due to transfers and injury.
Heard rave reviews from multiple members of the coaching staff about all three guys and what I saw of them impressed me.
Shetler: Who on the Panthers’ defense could you see taking a huge step forward, like Kyle Louis did a year ago?
Godsey: Cruce Brookins. He’ll be a starter at safety this year and he possesses pretty solid ball skills that should lead to interceptions. He’s already proven to be a good tackler, albeit in limited defensive snaps last season.
Shetler: What position of depth do you think is the biggest strength and the biggest weakness for Pitt entering this season?
Godsey: Linebacker is the best unit. Kyle Louis and Rasheem Biles showed the type of playmakers they are last season. Braylan Lovelace and Jeremiah Marcelin should both see some playing time at mike linebacker. Cam Lindsey also had a really nice spring and should be Louis’ backup at star linebacker.
Biggest weakness is probably the offensive line. The O-line was a problem last year. The coaching staff attacked OL hard in the portal and snagged a couple of tackles and a guard who look like better fits for Kade Bell’s offense, but until we see them play an actual game, it’s tough to say anything other than offensive line is the weakest position.
Shetler: Which opponents on the 2025 Pitt schedule could potentially be the hardest?
Godsey: Notre Dame, Miami, and Louisville are the toughest games on paper right now. Pitt gets all three at home but that doesn’t make it a whole lot easier. Louisville’s offense will likely be tough again. Notre Dame and Miami are two of their final three games of the season. The Irish are absolutely loaded coming into this year and should have one of the top defenses in college football. Miami is also loaded across the board. A lot hinges on the QBs for both the Irish and Hurricanes, but both squads have a lot of talent in the trenches, giving them an advantage over Pitt.
Shetler: Based on the second half collapse last season, if the Panthers were to take another step back this year, do you feel Pat Narduzzi should be on the hot seat?
Godsey: I think it depends on what qualifies as “another step back”—and I still think firing Narduzzi after the 2025 season is not likely to happen. He’s under contract through 2030 and makes around $7 million a year. I don’t think Pitt will want to be on the hook for an eight-figure buyout and also have to pay another coach on top of it.
Bryan Reynolds Reportedly Has No-Trade Clause with Six Playoff Teams
On Sunday, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Noah Hiles reported that Bryan Reynolds has a no-trade clause with six playoff teams. Those clubs include the Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Yankees, New York Mets, Toronto Blue Jays, San Diego Padres, and San Francisco Giants.
Reynolds is in his seventh season with the Pittsburgh Pirates. The switch-hitting outfielder has been struggling for much of 2025, with an OPS of .674 in 367 plate appearances.
The Pirates signed Reynolds in April of 2023, to an eight-year extension worth $106.75 million.
With the Bucs in obvious seller mode, it’s natural to think that Reynolds would be a trade candidate. Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic recently mentioned the Kansas City Royals having interest in the two-time All-Star.
In regards to the no-trade clause, it’s doesn’t seem like a coincidence that the teams exempt are locations with bigger tax rates.
The current trade value for Reynolds is tricky. While he does provide plenty of club control beyond this season - five years in fact - the offensive numbers are subpar this year. In addition, Reynolds has been a below average defender in the outfield for quite some time, and is on the other side of 30.
Recapping Day 1 of the NHL Free Agency Period for Penguins
Tuesday began the first official day for the NHL’s free agency period. Here is a recap of the moves.
The first move the Penguins made for Day 1 of the free agency period, was signing defenseman Parker Wotherspoon to a two-year contract with a $1 million AAV.
Last season, Wotherspoon played in 55 games with the Boston Bruins; recording 75 hits and 66 blocked shots.
The profile on Wotherspoon is a strong defender with mobility and solid, puck passing ability. At just $1 million, it’s a bargain for a third pairing dman.
A pair of forwards are back in the mix, as the Penguins have re-signed Connor Dewar and Phillip Tomasino.
Dewar was acquired from the Toronto Maple Leafs in March. The 5’10 center scored four goals in 17 games with Pittsburgh.
Tomasino joined the Penguins last November, as he was obtained from the Nashville Predators, in exchange for a 2027 fourth round draft pick. He recorded 11 goals in 50 games.
Dewar and Tomasino both showed flashes of being serviceable, bottom six forwards.
Another forward was added from the outside, as Justin Brazeau inked a two-year deal worth an AAV of $1.5 million.
In played 57 games last season with Boston, Brazeau scored 10 goals. At the trade deadline, he was moved to the Minnesota Wild. While with Minnesota, Brazeau registered only one goal in 19 games played. Combined for both teams, he compiled 123 hits.
Brazeau is a big-sized, forward at 6’6, 220 pounds. He will add size and physicality to Pittsburgh’s fourth line, along with some scoring ability. Penguins president of hockey operations, Kyle Dubas, has previous ties to Brazeau, as he signed him to an AHL contract with the Toronto Marlies in April of 2019.
Although Tuesday began the league’s free agency period, the Pens made their first notable trade of the offseason, as they moved veteran goaltender Alex Nedeljkovic to the San Jose Sharks for a 2028 third round pick.
Nedeljkovic was in net for two seasons with the Penguins - by and large as the backup to Tristan Jarry.
In 76 games for Pittsburgh, Nedeljkovic posted a 3.05 goals against average and a save percentage of .898.
Given the surplus of goaltending depth that the Penguins currently have, it’s not a surprise they made a veteran like Nedeljkovic expendable.
The Penguins brought in more depth on their blue line, with Caleb Jones, who signed a two-year contract, which includes a $900,000 cap hit.
Jones appeared in six games with the Los Angeles Kings this past season, but spent most of his time with their AHL affiliate, the Ontario Reign.
Over parts of seven NHL seasons, Jones has played for the Edmonton Oilers, Chicago Blackhawks, Colorado Avalanche, and the Kings. He’s the younger brother of Seth Jones, who became a first time Stanley Cup champion this year with the Florida Panthers.
Tyler Boyd Open to Signing with Steelers
While speaking at his youth football camp on Saturday, free agent wide receiver Tyler Boyd said he would “absolutely” be open to a homecoming with the Pittsburgh Steelers.
The former Clariton and University of Pittsburgh star entered the NFL as a second round draft selection of the Cincinnati Bengals in 2016.
Boyd played his first eight seasons in Cincinnati, where he compiled 6,000 receiving yards and 31 touchdowns.
Last offseason, Boyd reportedly had talks with the Steelers, before signing a one-year deal for $4.5 million with the Tennessee Titans.
Boyd started eight games with the Titans last year; recording 390 yards on 39 catches, but did not find the end zone.
In regards to Mike Tomlin, Boyd says he’s always maintained a good relationship with the Steelers head coach.
Based on the lack of interest in Boyd this offseason, Pittsburgh could probably sign him on the cheap. The Steelers’ WR depth is currently thin, so perhaps it wouldn’t hurt taking a flyer on Boyd.
Isaac Mattson: A Western Pennsylvania Journey
p/c: Gene J. Puskar
Born and raised in Erie, Pennsylvania, Isaac Mattson was a pitcher for Harbor Creek High School, located near his hometown.
In 2014, Mattson enrolled at the University of Pittsburgh. During his three years with the Panthers as a reliever, he compiled a 3.47 ERA.
Mattson was taken as a 19th round selection of the Los Angeles Angels in the 2017 MLB Draft.
Shortly after representing the Angels in the 2019 Arizona Fall League, Mattson was traded to the Baltimore Orioles, in a deal involving former top pitching prospect Dylan Bundy.
2021 was a rollercoaster year for Mattson, as while he did receive his first big league call up, his mother tragically took her own life.
Mattson returned to Western Pennsylvania in 2022 by signing with the Washington Wild Things of the Frontier League; located about 40 minutes south of Pittsburgh. The right-hander posted an ERA of 2.40 in 12 relief outings. Despite the good ERA, his contract option was declined by the Wild Things.
Heading into 2023, Mattson chose to stay the independent ball route, as he inked a deal with the Atlantic League’s Southern Maryland Blue Crabs. In 18 games, he put up a 3.32 ERA.
Impressed by his stint in independent ball, the Minnesota Twins signed Mattson to a minor league contract, and he was assigned to AA Wichita, where he had a 3.62 ERA. Following the season, he elected free agency.
After pitching collegiately and independently, in Western PA, it was the Pittsburgh Pirates’ turn to give him a chance, as they signed him to a minor league deal, prior to the 2024. It was on September 19th that he made his return to an MLB mound.
The Pirates removed Mattson from the 40-man roster on November 4th, which prompted him to elect free agency. Two weeks later, however, he re-signed an MiLB deal with Pittsburgh.
Mattson began 2025 with AAA Indianapolis. He registered an ERA of 2.57, along with a 0.95 WHIP, and a 10.7 K/9 (25 K in 21 IP). The Indians were using him mostly in high leverage situations late in games.
On May 20th, the Pirates selected Mattson’s contract and added him to the active roster. He’s been a good, middle relief option for Pittsburgh thru 10 appearances, with a 2.03 ERA and a WHIP of 0.60.
Perseverance has been the name of the game for Mattson’s journey in professional baseball, particularly in Western Pennsylvania, and the hard work could finally lead to an opportunity to be a mainstay in a Major League bullpen.
Penguins’ Asking Price for Rickard Rakell Needs to Remain Sky High
When mentioning the name Ron Hextall to a Pittsburgh Penguins fan, it’s enough for them to have a bottle of Pepto Bismol on standby.
While Hextall’s tenure was mainly forgettable, as Pens general manager, he made objectively his best move at the 2022 trade deadline - acquiring Rickard Rakell from the Anaheim Ducks. Later that offseason, Hextall extended Rakell by signing him to a six-year extension worth $30 million.
Following an injury-plagued, 2023-24 campaign, in which he only put up 15 goals, Rakell bounced back in a big way last season, as he led the Penguins with a career-high 35 goals.
Pittsburgh found themselves in seller mode at the trade deadline. The biggest move was trading their best defenseman, Marcus Pettersson, to the Vancouver Canucks. Tons of speculation circulated around Rakell being a possible trade piece, but the veteran forward wasn’t dealt.
Reports had surfaced after the deadline that Kyle Dubas’ asking price for Rakell was a pair of first round picks, as well as a top prospect. Apparently, other teams weren’t willing to go that high.
With the NHL free agency period beginning July 1st, the two biggest wingers on the open market will be Mitch Marner and Brock Boeser.
Early rumblings from insiders are that Marner could receive up to $14 million annually, in the 7-8 year range. As for Boeser, the projected figure is expected to be $8+ million, for about the same length.
It’s likely that teams who will be in the sweepstakes, for either Marner or Boeser’s services, might go the trade route with Rakell, if they lose out on both.
Rakell is under contract with the Penguins the next three seasons, with an AAV of $5 million, which is a bargain, for a proven 30-goal scorer. While getting Rakell would obviously involve moving significant, draft capital, and probably a top end prospect, the money is much more favorable, to a forward that I think is equally as good as Marner and Boeser.
Personally, Dubas shouldn’t budge off his asking price for Rakell, given the production, years of control, and reasonable amount. If a team truly views itself as a Stanley Cup contender, and they feel Rakell can be that missing piece to their Top 6 puzzle, then that team needs to aim extremely high.
Examining Andrew McCutchen’s Hall of Fame Case
On Wednesday afternoon, the Pittsburgh Pirates defeated the Miami Marlins by a final of 5-2. The most notable scoring for the Bucs came on an Andrew McCutchen three-run blast, which helped him surpass Roberto Clemente for sole possession of third on the Pirates’ all-time home run list.
Ironically, it was two years ago to the day that McCutchen recorded the 2,000th hit of his Major League career.
When all is said and done, McCutchen will no doubt be an honorary member of the Pirates’ Hall of Fame, and will most likely have his uniform number 22 retired by the franchise. But is McCutchen Cooperstown worthy? Let’s examine his case.
From 2011-2015, McCutchen was undoubtedly among the best players in MLB. During each of those five seasons, he was voted into the Midsummer Classic. He would capture four Silver Slugger awards, and become the first Pirates player since Barry Bonds in 1992, to win the National League MVP, which he did in 2013.
In terms of McCutchen’s offensive value, he was extraordinary once he entered his prime; leading the NL in oWAR (7.5 in 2012, 7.5 in 2013 and 7.7 in 2014).
McCutchen’s career oWAR has held up extremely well, as his 58.0 mark is Top 15 among center fielders all-time at 14.
For as great as the offensive profile is, in regards to McCutchen, the defensive metrics tell another story. His -10.1 dWAR knock down his career WAR at 49.6, which is 32nd all-time. In addition, McCutchen’s career Defensive Runs Saves figure is brutal at -62.
There are currently 19 center fielders who are in the Hall of Fame. Going by JAWS (Jay Jaffe’s WAR Score), a system that factors in a player’s career WAR, along with their seven-year peak, McCutchen is 27th among all-time center fielders.
In conclusion, I would have to concur with JAWS that McCutchen falls short of being a Hall of Famer. While he has the same exact oWAR as Kenny Lofton, the overall WAR is much higher for Lofton, because of him being a substantially, better defensive center fielder. Bernie Williams, who isn’t in the Hall of Fame either, had the same career WAR as McCutchen, however, Williams not only had the higher oWAR, but you obviously have to point out his decorated postseason numbers.
If McCutchen had played at an MVP, or even an All-Star level another 3-4 years, following 2015, and/or played league average defense, for most of his career, then we’re probably talking definite enshrinement into Cooperstown.
Realistically, it seems unlikely McCutchen would get voted in, while he’s on the ballot, so perhaps there’s a chance he gets elected by a committee - similar to Dave Parker last offseason.
Five Biggest X-Factors for Steelers In 2025
For somebody to suggest the 2025 Pittsburgh Steelers’ offseason has been a crazy one would be a vast understatement.
It’s an offseason that’s consisted of a mega deal involving DK Metcalf, a trade of George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys, and the addition of future Hall of Famer, Aaron Rodgers.
By and large, the Steelers have an idea of what to expect from their talent. But here are five players, who will be labeled as X-Factors, for the upcoming season.
Broderick Jones
The Pittsburgh Steelers selected Broderick Jones 14th overall in the 2023 NFL Draft out of the University of Georgia.
Given how high the Steelers were on Dan Moore Jr. at left tackle, Jones was moved over to the right side of the offensive line, which felt like a peculiar move.
Moore signed a free agent deal this offseason with the Tennessee Titans, so Jones will get the chance to start at his natural position of LT.
Coming out of college, Jones was a good, run blocker. However, his pass blocking was considered by most scouts as a work in progress. 2025 will no doubt be a make or break season for Jones, as he will tasked with protecting Aaron Rodgers’ blindside.
Cole Holcomb
In March of 2023, the Steelers signed inside linebacker Cole Holcomb to a three-year contract worth $18 million.
During the 2023 season, Holcomb suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 9. Before going down, he compiled 54 combined tackles, along with two forced fumbles.
Holcomb spent the entirety of last year on the Steelers’ PUP list.
Since Holcomb’s injury, Pittsburgh has added Pro Bowl ILB Patrick Queen and 2024 third round pick Payton Wilson, who is coming off a quality, rookie campaign. Malik Harrison, a teammate of Queen’s in Baltimore, will likely compete with Holcomb as the Steelers ILB3. If Holcomb can win the job, and more importantly return to full health, the production he could provide be an added bonus to the ILB depth.
Kaleb Johnson
Despite four straight seasons of 1,000 rushing yards, the Steelers decided to move on from Najee Harris. The former first round selection signed a one-year deal with the Los Angeles Chargers.
As expected, a running back was addressed in the 2025 draft, with Pittsburgh taking University of Iowa standout Kaleb Johnson in the third round. The pick has been considered one of the bigger mid-round steals in the draft.
Last season as a junior, Johnson rushed for 1,537 yards and 21 touchdowns; both of which are now single-season school records. In addition, he was named Big Ten Running Back of the Year.
Jaylen Warren is projected to be the Steelers feature RB this season. Although much like Harris, he probably won’t get a large majority of the carries. Mike Tomlin has been impressed so far with the rookie Johnson, in minicamp and OTAs, so perhaps he could be a favorite as the RB2 behind Warren. The Steelers also signed former Philadelphia Eagles tailback Kenneth Gainwell this offseason.
Roman Wilson
Looking to add to the wide receiver depth last year, the Steelers drafted Roman Wilson as a third round selection.
Wilson had a very productive collegiate career at Michigan, where he played a vital role, on the Wolverines’ 2023 National Championship team.
It was a rough beginning to Wilson’s pro football journey, as he dealt with a significant ankle injury, which caused him to miss the rest of training camp and the preseason. He made his debut for the Steelers in Week 6, but only received five offensive snaps.
On October 28th, Wilson sustained a hamstring injury that landed him on injured reserve, and resulted in his season being over.
With the departure of Pickens, Pittsburgh has yet to address a true, WR2 replacement, and it’s unclear whether they will at this point. Regardless if they do or not, it’s imperative Wilson remains on the field. Should that happen and he plays up to his potential, it would be a big, shot in the arm, for the Steelers’ offense in 2025.
Troy Fautanu
After drafting Broderick Jones in 2023, Pittsburgh went the offensive line route again, with their first round pick in 2024, choosing University of Washington right tackle Troy Fautanu.
Entering the ‘24 draft, Fautanu was widely regarded as one of the top offensive tackles in the draft. During his redshirt senior year, he was recognized as the Morris Trophy winner, an award given out to the best offensive lineman in the Pac-12.
For Fautanu, joining the Steelers was a dream come true, as he idolized Troy Polamalu. So much so that he copied his style of play from Polamalu. It was shortly after being drafted that the Steelers Hall of Fame safety personally congratulated Fautanu.
In the preseason opener, Fautanu dealt with a knee injury. He would make his debut in Week 2 against the Denver Broncos. However, on September 20th, Fautanu left practice and underwent an MRI. The next day, he was placed on IR. On September 23rd, the diagnosis of Fautanu’s injury was not promising, as he dislocated his kneecap, which ended his season.
Fautanu will open this year as the Steelers starting right tackle. Out of all the X-Factors that were mentioned, Fantanu would seem to be the least to be concerned about, given how polished he was coming out of college. Assuming Fautanu returns back fully healthy, he’s got the upside of a Pro Bowl caliber RT.
Gabe Davis to Visit Steelers on Thursday
ESPN’s Adam Schefter is reporting that free agent wide receiver Gabe Davis will be traveling to Pittsburgh on Wednesday, for a meeting with the Steelers on Thursday.
The Buffalo Bills selected Davis as a fourth round pick in the 2020 draft out of UCF.
Davis played four seasons for Buffalo, with his best year coming in 2022, when he recorded 836 receiving yards and seven touchdowns.
In March of 2024, the Jacksonville Jaguars inked Davis to a three-year contract worth $39 million; $24 million of which was guaranteed.
Davis played in only 10 games with the Jags last year, as his season was cut short due to a torn meniscus.
In regards to the Steelers’ WR room, it’s been a crazy offseason, to say the least, with the blockbuster deal of DK Metcalf, as well as George Pickens getting traded to the Dallas Cowboys.
The Steelers had been linked to Davis earlier in the offseason, so it appears the two sides will meet this week, to possibly get a deal done. Assuming full health, Davis could be an intriguing, addition.
The other notable WR the Steelers added was veteran Robert Woods, who signed with the team on a one-year deal for $2 million.
Pirates Q & A Mailbag
My latest for Burgh Sports United will be answering questions regarding your Pittsburgh Pirates. All of these questions were asked via Twitter/X, so let’s dive right into it.
Both IKF and Andrew Heaney are both rentals, so the return on each will likely be decent, but not great. Given David Bednar’s team control, there could be a quality bat obtained; assuming Bednar continues to pitch well heading into the deadline. As for Tommy Pham, he might just be a DFA candidate. If they do get *anything* for Pham, perhaps they flip him for international bonus pool money.
The decision to have Carmen Mlodzinski start was probably his choice. Although I agree, Mlodzinski is a better option in the bullpen, and would improve that area, in the later innings.
At this point, Don Kelly should be looking to play younger options, such as Alexander Canario over Pham, and recalling Nick Yorke, while moving on from Adam Frazier.
Bubba Chandler’s time in Pittsburgh is likely to come very soon. Wouldn’t surprise me if he’s called up during the Pirates’ next homestand.
You’re right, there hasn’t been an urgency to find impact bats, however, perhaps that changes at the deadline. Dennis Santana’s trade value is very high, so the Bucs could look to sell high, to get themselves a return headlined by a bonafide, MLB ready bat.
Nick Solak should get more play over Jared Triolo because he’s a better option offensively. I get it, Triolo’s defense is as solid as they come, for a utility infielder, but sometimes you need to sacrifice some defense for a hitter, who isn’t going to be an automatic out in the lineup. Am I suggesting Solak will be a difference maker for the Pirates? No. However, I do think he’s at least capable of being a serviceable, platoon type batter.
Obviously, the Pirates need to identify which core position players are capable of building around moving forward. The biggest thing that must change is their ability to develop hitters, which has been a real sore spot during Ben Cherington’s tenure. The starting rotation is a solid, foundation to work off of. When the Pirates had their postseason run from 2013-15, it consisted of a core of very good younger players, and quality, veterans, within the lineup, rotation, and bullpen. It may not be an easy recipe to replicate, but it’s one that will get the Bucs back to that point.
While I do think the end should be near for Cherington, I personally would only allow him to make trades on rental players, like IKF, Andrew Heaney, and Caleb Ferguson. Another GM should be tasked with trading away controllable assets for bigger returns.
Elbow Surgery Could Be an Option for Jared Jones
Following a sweep to the Philadelphia Phillies over the weekend, which put them a season worst 17 games under .500 at 15-32, the Pittsburgh Pirates received some potentially bad news, as MLB.com’s Alex Stumpf is reporting that Jared Jones is looking for a second opinion regarding his elbow. He’s expected to meet with Dr. Keith Meister on Tuesday about whether surgery will be an option.
Much like Paul Skenes, Jones burst onto the big league scene last year, as a member of the Pirates’ rotation. In his first 16 starts, he posted a 3.56 ERA.
On July 5th, Jones sustained a lat muscle strain. The 23-year-old right-hander returned in late August, but wasn’t as effective, with an ERA of 5.87.
Before making his final scheduled start of spring training, Jones experienced elbow discomfort. It was announced on March 25th that he would go on a six week rest period without throwing.
Apparently there was a setback in Jones’ throwing program recently, which is now why he will seek a second opinion. If Jones were to undergo Tommy John surgery, he would of course miss the rest of the season, and a large majority of 2026.
Pirates to Activate Spencer Horwitz
p/c: Charles LeClaire
The Pittsburgh Pirates are activating first baseman Spencer Horwitz for Friday’s game against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park.
Horwitz was acquired by the Pirates from the Cleveland Guardians at this past offseason’s Winter Meetings, in exchange for pitchers Luis Ortiz, Michael Kennedy, and Josh Hartle.
Last year, Horwitz slashed .285/.380/.484 vs RHP, with the Toronto Blue Jays.
On February 12th, the Pirates announced that Horwitz had underwent wrist surgery, which was expected to keep him out, for the entirety of spring training.
Horwitz began his rehab assignment on April 27th with AA Altoona, where he went 2-for-16 (.125 average).
The Pirates transferred Horwitz’s rehab to AAA Indianapolis on May 6th. While playing for the Indians, he was 10-for-31 (.323 average).
It will be interesting to see if Pirates manager Don Kelly uses Horwitz as an everyday first baseman.
Examining Trade Candidates for Pirates
As this post is written, the Pittsburgh Pirates are 13-27. Fresh off firing Derek Shelton as manager this week, it appears the team is already finding themselves in a position to be sellers.
So which Pirates players could be on the trade block? Let’s examine several candidates.
Most likely candidates:
Andrew Heaney: The Pirates signed Andrew Heaney this past offseason to a one-year deal for $5.2 million.
In his first eight starts with Pittsburgh, Heaney has registered a 3.18 ERA.
Assuming Heaney continues to provide steady numbers in the Pirates’ rotation, he should definitely be on the move.
Caleb Ferguson: With the departure of Aroldis Chapman, the Pirates brought in multiple lefty relievers for bullpen depth. One of those was Caleb Ferguson, who inked a one-year deal for $3 million.
Ferguson to this point has an ERA of 4.15, along with a 3.69 FIP, in 19 appearances.
Contending teams are always in search of left-handed relief help, and I would expect Ferguson to draw some interest.
Isiah Kiner-Falefa: Acquired from the Toronto Blue Jays at last year’s trade deadline, Isiah Kiner-Falefa entered this season as the Pirates everyday shortstop.
Currently on the injured list, with a hamstring issue, Kiner-Falefa is hitting .280, but only posting a .660 OPS.
Before arriving to Pittsburgh, IKF had been mainly in a super utility role, so I would expect that whichever contender trades for him, will use him in a similar way.
50/50 candidates:
Adam Frazier: After playing his first six big league seasons with the Pirates, Adam Frazier returned to Pittsburgh this year, on a one-year deal worth $1.5 million.
Frazier is filling in as the Pirates second baseman for the injured Nick Gonzales. It’s been a struggle offensively, with an OPS of .594.
Defensively, the 33-year-old Frazier has been surprisingly, solid at second base; recording +4 Defensive Runs Saved.
Frazier has played on contending clubs the past couple years. It’s possible that the Pirates would use Frazier as a thrown in piece for a package deal.
David Bednar: Following back-to-back All-Star campaigns, David Bednar had a season from hell in 2024, with a 5.77 ERA.
After scuffling in three games during the Pirates’ opening series of the season against the Miami Marlins, Bednar was optioned to AAA Indianapolis.
Since being recalled from Indy on April 19th, the Pittsburgh native has looked good, registering a 1.80 ERA.
If Bednar were to return anywhere near the level of his All-Star form, then he certainly could be on the block.
Dennis Santana: While the Pirates’ bullpen mostly underperformed last season, Dennis Santana became a bright spot for them. Claimed off waivers from the New York Yankees, Santana dazzled, to the tune of a 2.44 ERA.
In the early portion of 2025, Santana is in the closer role for the Pirates. In his first 16 appearances, he’s put up a 2.35 ERA, along with a 0.98 WHIP.
Santana is owed just $1.4 million this year, and is under team control through next season, so he could bring back a nice, return, if the Pirates decide to sell high.
Joey Bart: Looking to add catching depth, the Bucs acquired former top prospect Joey Bart from the San Francisco Giants a year ago.
Bart provided quite a spark, to a lackluster, Pirates’ offense in ‘24, as he slashed .265/.337/.462, while hitting 13 homers, and posting a 2.1 oWAR.
So far this season, Bart has done a terrific, job reaching base, with a strong, .412 OBP, However, the power hasn’t been there, as he’s only putting up a slugging percentage of .378.
Behind the plate, Bart’s blocking ability and pitch framing have both received negative reviews.
It’ll be interesting to see how much interest Bart will garner from other teams as a catcher. Perhaps there’s a chance that he’s viewed as an inexpensive, DH option.
Least likely candidates:
Bryan Reynolds: Signed by the Pirates to a $106.75 million dollar extension, in April of 2023, Bryan Reynolds has been a catalyst for the lineup.
It’s been a brutal start to ‘25 for the switch-hitting Reynolds, slashing only .215/.276/.342, in 174 plate appearances.
When factoring in his below average defense, he’s got a bWAR and fWAR of -0.7 and -0.3 respectively.
Reynolds has a history of slow starts, and typically heats up, as the season progresses. Even if that were the case this year, the Pirates still probably consider Reynolds as a vital piece of their offense moving forward.
Mitch Keller: In February of 2024, the Pirates made Mitch Keller the richest pitcher in franchise history by inking him to five-year extension worth $77 million.
Aside from being able to cover innings, Keller has led all of MLB in strike outs looking since the start of 2023.
Through his first eight starts of this season, the 29-year-old righty has an ERA of 4.40, but a better 3.68 FIP.
Given the amount of arms in the Pirates’ system, who are MLB ready, one can make a valid case that Keller should be expendable, as a way to add much needed bats. The problem however would seem to be the Pirates overvaluing Keller as a #2 pitcher in the rotation, where as contenders with better pitching staffs, probably see more as an above average fourth starter. Because of this, it appears doubtful that the Bucs would get that big time haul for Keller.
Pirates Fire Derek Shelton
Following a 12-26 start to the season, the Pittsburgh Pirates have relieved Derek Shelton of his duties as manager. Bench coach Don Kelly will take over on an interim basis.
Shelton was hired by the Pirates in November of 2019 - replacing Clint Hurdle.
During Shelton’s first season, in the Covid-shortened 2020, Pittsburgh finished with the worst record at 19-41.
After back-to-back 100-loss campaigns in 2021 and 2022, the Pirates got off to an amazing, 20-8 start in 2023 - only to collapse in May - and still finish under .500 at 76-86.
Despite being buyers last year, Shelton’s team fell apart in the second half, as they went 21-34 post trade deadline.
Among Pirates managers, who have managed at least 500 games, Shelton finishes with the worst winning percentage at .410.
Tommy Pham Signing Personifies Pirates’ Embarrassing Offense
In 2024, the Pittsburgh Pirates’ offense set a franchise record for most strikeouts in a season, which led to the firing of hitting coach Andy Haines.
Presumably on the hot seat, general manager Ben Cherington had to go into this past offseason looking to make significant upgrades to the offense.
The first notable move was at the Winter Meetings, when Cherington dealt pitchers Luis Ortiz, Michael Kennedy, and Josh Hartle, in order to acquire first baseman Spencer Horwitz from the Cleveland Guardians. Considered Pittsburgh’s best offseason addition, Horwitz has yet to even suit up with the Pirates, and is currently on rehab assignment.
Aside from first base, corner outfield was another spot that needed to be addressed. This came in the form of 37-year-old Tommy Pham, who signed with the Bucs for $4 million.
Entering the first week of May, the Pirates currently have the second worst team OPS in the National League at .644. Pham has been a microcosm of their offensive woes.
The numbers offensively for Pham tell a bleak story to this point.
Literally the only redeeming quality with Pham at the plate is not chasing pitches. But despite that positive attribute, both the contact and power figures are extremely poor. Pham’s 37.9% hard hit rate is on track to be the worst of his career. He’s also really struggling against left-handed pitching; slashing .208/.240/.208, with no extra-base hits. Among qualified NL players, Pham has the lowest wRC+ at 28.
Even with the surprisingly, good defense from Pham (+6 Defensive Runs Saved), he’s still been a replacement level player overall (-0.1 bWAR).
Objectively, the Pham signing is not only the most pathetic by the Pirates last offseason, but you can make a sound argument that it was the worst free agent signing of the entire MLB offseason as a whole.
At a time when the Pirates have one of the strongest farm systems, in terms of pitching prospect talent, the initiative should have been to deal from strength by trading an upside arm, to acquire a controllable, impact corner outfield bat for the lineup. But instead, Cherington opted to go the weakest route; bringing in a washed up version of Pham. It’s a decision that no doubt has affected the Pirates’ offense immensely, and one which will likely cost Cherington and Derek Shelton their jobs.